Skip to main content
Question

Customer making payments on updated smart file without approving changes

  • August 10, 2025
  • 6 replies
  • 26 views

Oyinka Coakley
Forum|alt.badge.img

Why is a client allowed to make payments on a smart file that has been updated without first approving those updates???
 

A customer asked to add another service to her invoice after making the first payment. I updated her invoice and contract in her smart file and emailed it to her for approval. She never approved the changes. However, she did make the other two payments in the payment schedule. Now she wants to cancel her booking and says she never signed the contract because the latest version visible to her does not include her signature. The previous version does include her signature but that version is a different amount than she paid. I know this is going to lead to a chargeback of at least $2,000.
 

Why would HoneyBook allow customers to pay the unapproved amount? The system should force the client to approve changes before additional payments can be made. Now the customer has made payments on the unapproved amount and I don’t have a contract proving she agreed to the changes. The HB representative says the system is “working as intended” so this must be submitted as a feature request. 
 

In my opinion, this is not a feature request. This is a fatal flaw in the system that will lead to chargebacks which not only affects me. It affects HoneyBook as well. I process hundreds of thousands of dollars in smart files in HB every year so I don’t have time to click on every smart file to see which ones have unapproved changes. What can be done to correct this?

6 replies

Shannon Ranger
Explorer
Forum|alt.badge.img

YIKES!!!! That’s a pretty big concern!


Alicia Bauer
Forum|alt.badge.img+4
  • Newcomer
  • August 11, 2025

@Oyinka Coakley - Thanks so much for sharing this, it definitely sounds like something that could use a closer look. I’m going to tag ​@Monica R  and ​@Kait M  to review your experience and confirm whether there are any updates or internal workarounds in place for situations like this.

Appreciate you raising it here so others can stay informed, too!


Oyinka Coakley
Forum|alt.badge.img

Thank you for your reply. I appreciate you looking into this. What makes this matter even worse is when I download the previous version that she did sign, it does not download as it appears on screen. Several chunks of text are missing on the PDF download, mostly where the smart fields are in the contract. The HB representative did submit a ticket regarding the missing text on the download. Hopefully that can be resolved as well. 


Oyinka Coakley
Forum|alt.badge.img

As a result of this issue, I just received a $2,800 chargeback. That is an astronomical amount of money for a small business owner to lose. To make matters worse, the issue of the system allowing clients to make payments on a revised contract has not been resolved. Another client just did the same thing yesterday. I have sent the client multiple emails asking them to approve the revisions but they haven’t. What is HoneyBook going to do to resolve this issue? ​@Alicia Bauer ​@Kait M ​@Monica R 


Alicia Bauer
Forum|alt.badge.img+4
  • Newcomer
  • August 28, 2025

@Oyinka Coakley - I'm very sorry you're dealing with this, that’s an incredibly tough situation, and I can completely understand your frustration.

Just to clarify, I’m a fellow community member and not a HoneyBook employee. Unfortunately I’m not able to make any changes or offer direct support. I’d strongly encourage you to reach out to the HoneyBook team directly using the ? icon in the bottom right corner of your dashboard if you haven’t already, they’re the best resource for escalating issues like this.

I really hope they’re able to address this and implement a solution to prevent situations like this moving forward. 💛


Monica R
HoneyBook Community Team
Forum|alt.badge.img+7
  • HoneyBook Community Team
  • August 29, 2025

Hey ​@Oyinka Coakley,

I’m so sorry this happened! I’ve spoken to the Support team and know they’re working to get things resolved asap!